Temporary hearing changes and tinnitus after loud music
Evidence basis: randomised trials
Earplugs reduced temporary hearing changes and new tinnitus after one loud music festival.
Population: 51 mostly young, normal-hearing adults at one Dutch music festival; fitting results come from 140 participants in workplace trials.
Research details
Summary
A randomized trial assigned 51 normal-hearing adults to earplugs or no protection during a 4½-hour festival averaging 100 dBA. Temporary threshold shifts at 3 and 4 kHz occurred in 4 of 50 protected ears (8%) versus 22 of 52 unprotected ears (42%). New tinnitus was reported by 3 of 25 protected participants (12%) versus 10 of 25 unprotected participants (40%). Separately, a Cochrane workplace review found that insertion instructions improved earplug attenuation by 8.59 dB (95% CI 6.92 to 10.25) in two trials with 140 participants.
Why this certainty
Limited certainty reflects a randomized comparison with clear short-term differences but a small sample and narrow setting. The review supports fitting instruction, without establishing a fixed protection level for all users.
Limitations
The festival trial was small, single-event and focused on immediate effects rather than permanent hearing loss. Hearing-threshold counts are ears, whereas tinnitus counts are people. Workplace fitting results do not predict the attenuation of every product in recreational use.
Effect estimate
Temporary threshold shift: 8% of protected ears versus 42% of unprotected ears after the festival.
